How Forrest Baumhover Recovered $10K in Monthly Traffic

On May 31, 2025

In this week’s episode of the Niche Pursuits podcast, Forrest Baumhover shares an inspiring story of recovery. Forrest’s personal finance website, TeachMePersonalFinance.com, was devastated by Google’s Helpful Content Update (HCU), dropping to ranking for only 16 keywords at its lowest point.

Yet, through persistence, strategic content creation, and smart integration of YouTube, Forrest has rebuilt the site to a point where it now earns around $10,000 per month from ads, including revenue from both the website and a thriving YouTube channel.

This story is not just about SEO tactics or content strategies. It’s about resilience and sticking with a vision, even when the outlook seems bleak. Forrest’s experience provides a roadmap for anyone struggling with sudden traffic drops or algorithm changes, showing how to adapt and come back stronger.

Watch the Full Episode

Forrest’s Background and How the Website Began

Forrest’s journey starts long before TeachMePersonalFinance.com. After a career in the Navy, he transitioned into financial planning and eventually sold his partnership to a financial firm. With a strong foundation in personal finance and years of writing articles for his practice, Forrest wanted to build something of his own. On this site, he could share valuable financial information.

He acquired TeachMePersonalFinance.com from a previous owner who had outsourced low-quality content.
Forrest initially inherited about 150 low-quality articles but brought his own 80+ articles to the table, aiming to improve and grow the site.
His approach combined learning SEO tools like Ahrefs with a focus on writing genuinely helpful content for his audience.

Forrest viewed the site as a “blank enough slate” with some existing brand history but enough room to pivot and create his own direction.

Early Growth and Content Strategy

In the early days, Forrest concentrated on improving existing content while consistently producing new articles — about 12 to 15 per month. The personal finance niche is broad, so he focused on specific areas where he had experience and saw an opportunity:

Tax forms and Social Security forms became key content pillars.
Forrest created a detailed spreadsheet to prioritize which articles to write based on keyword difficulty and audience needs.
His goal was to cover complex financial topics step-by-step, helping readers navigate confusing tax forms with clarity.

This thoughtful approach helped build traction, but the real challenge was just ahead.

The Impact of Google’s Helpful Content Update

In September 2023, the Helpful Content Update hit. Forrest describes this period as “devastating” for the site’s Google rankings. From peaking at around 14,000 keywords, the site fell to ranking for only 16 keywords by summer 2024.

Despite the drop in Google rankings, Forrest noticed his site’s overall analytics still showed growth year-over-year.
Interestingly, much of his traffic was coming from Bing and even AOL, not Google.
Instead of panicking, Forrest doubled down on content creation and kept faith that Google would eventually recognize the quality of his site again.

His experience highlights how Google’s signals can sometimes be confusing and why persistence is crucial.

Doubling Down on YouTube: A Key to Recovery

During this difficult period, Forrest started a faceless YouTube channel to complement the website’s written content. This became a major factor in the site’s recovery:

Forrest created screen-recorded tutorial videos on tax forms, breaking down complicated topics visually.
He embedded these videos in his articles and linked them back and forth between YouTube and the site.
The YouTube channel grew quickly, reaching over 15,000 subscribers with nearly 700 videos published.

This cross-platform strategy helped drive traffic and engagement, giving Google additional signals about the site’s usefulness.

The Comeback: Recovery and Growth Post-Update

By December 2024, a Google core update began restoring the site’s rankings dramatically. Forrest’s site went from near-zero keywords back to surpassing previous traffic levels.

The combination of consistent article updates, strong internal linking, and YouTube videos helped fuel this rebound.
Forrest also uses tools like Link Whisper to enhance article interlinking.
Mediavine approval in 2024 has helped monetize the traffic with much higher RPMs than before.

Today, Forrest estimates that the website and YouTube together bring in around $10,000 per month, though he notes seasonality affects earnings.

Monetization and Future Plans

Beyond ads, Forrest has begun exploring additional monetization streams:

He recently obtained a tax preparation license and now offers tax return services.
He’s developing one-on-one tax planning sessions targeting DIY tax filers who want expert help.
This expansion leverages his personal finance expertise and aligns well with his content audience.

Forrest’s story shows how content creators can evolve from pure publishing into service-based offerings for diversified income.

Key Takeaways from Forrest’s Recovery Journey

Forrest’s story stands out for several reasons that can inspire anyone dealing with setbacks in their online business:

Staying consistent during difficult times is essential, even when Google’s signals seem contradictory.
Combining written content with complementary YouTube videos can create powerful cross-platform synergy.
Using data and SEO tools to prioritize content and improve linking helps build authority over time.
Diversifying monetization beyond ads, especially in niches with expert knowledge, can boost long-term sustainability.

His experience reinforces that with patience and smart strategy, a site can recover and thrive even after devastating algorithm hits.

Final Thoughts

Forrest Baumhover’s journey with TeachMePersonalFinance.com is a powerful reminder that setbacks don’t have to be the end of the road. The drastic impact of Google’s Helpful Content Update could have sunk the site permanently, but Forrest’s commitment to quality content, paired with a smart YouTube strategy, fueled a remarkable comeback.

For anyone navigating the uncertainty of SEO or algorithm changes, Forrest’s story offers encouragement to stay the course and keep refining your strategy. The integration of different content formats, consistent publishing, and a focus on genuinely helping the audience can eventually pay off, even when it feels like the odds are stacked against you.

If you’re inspired by Forrest’s story, consider how you might diversify your content, experiment with new platforms, or develop complementary services to support your niche. Sometimes, the key to recovery lies not just in what you create, but in how you connect it all together.

links & resources

Source link